Since opening five decades ago, Aunt Polly's has become a cornerstone of Indianapolis’s East Side community. Started by a dedicated family, we've upheld a tradition of homemade cooking, using recipes passed down through generations. Our commitment is simple: serve authentic, hearty dishes that bring comfort and happiness. We bake our pizza over open flames to create that perfect balance of crispy dough and rich toppings. Our ribs are slow-cooked until tender and glazed with our signature BBQ sauce, appealing to even the pickiest eaters.
We take pride in welcoming a diverse crowd, from families with children to university students and LGBTQ+ friends, all in a casual, historic setting. Our mission extends beyond just good food; we aim to provide a safe, friendly environment where community bonds strengthen over shared meals. Every day, we strive to show appreciation for our loyal customers, many of whom have celebrated birthdays, anniversaries, and milestones right here.
