Step into Aunt Polly's, a beloved mom-and-pop eatery that has been serving Indianapolitans for over 50 years. Located at 5339 English Ave on the East Side, this local gem offers a hearty menu packed with comfort food favorites. From crispy wings and tender ribs to classic New York-style pizza, Aunt Polly's satisfies a variety of cravings. Try their signature open-flame cooked pizza, renowned for its authentic flavor and crispy crust. Whether you're dropping in for lunch, dinner, or late-night bites, the menu's generous options and affordable prices make Aunt Polly's a true community favorite.
Delivery services enable you to enjoy their food anywhere on Indianapolis' East Side, bringing family warmth straight to your door. With friendly staff and a welcoming vibe, this spot feels like eating at a neighbor’s house—only with better food and a dash of history.
Walking into Aunt Polly's feels like stepping into a piece of local history—a casual, quiet space with a cozy vibe. The staff greets you with genuine friendliness, making every visit feel personal. The interior isn’t fancy; it bears the charm of a decades-old mom-and-pop shop, with simple seating that’s wheelchair accessible. Open kitchen views reveal flames dancing under pizza decks, adding an authentic touch to every slice. Despite its modest appearance, the atmosphere buzzes with family-friendly chatter, perfect for leisurely meals or quick bites between errands. Whether you dine in or order out, the aroma of freshly baked breadsticks, sizzling wings, and smoky ribs fills the air, tempting passersby. Aunt Polly’s isn’t just about food; it's about community, tradition, and a late-night haven for locals and visitors alike.
Aunt Polly's specializes in classic comfort foods with a local twist. Their pizza, cooked over open flames on stone decks, delivers a smoky, crunchy crust that hooks even the toughest pizza critic. The menu boasts giant 18-inch two-topping pies, with specialties like stromboli, Italian subs, and hearty sandwiches that hit the spot. Fans flock for the wings, available in various sauces—BBQ, Buffalo, garlic parmesan, and sweet chili—that remain crispy and flavorful. Ribs come slow-cooked and slathered with rich BBQ sauce, while chicken tenders and tenderloin sandwiches make perfect quick bites. The family pizza deal, which includes breadsticks and a 2-liter soda, offers incredible value at just $24.99. Aunt Polly’s commitment to quality and tradition ensures each dish tastes like a homemade family recipe, perfect for feeding large groups or solo diners craving genuine Indiana flavor.
At Aunt Polly's, we commit to serving authentic, handcrafted comfort foods that celebrate family and local tradition. Our specialty lies in flame-baked pizzas, tender ribs, and crispy wings—recipes passed down through generations. Our vision focuses on community health, affordability, and loyalty. We aim to be Indianapolis' go-to spot for genuine flavors, welcoming everyone from local families to university students. As a LGBTQ+ friendly and transgender-safe space, we believe diversity enriches our community. Every dish reflects our dedication to quality, sustainability, and heartfelt service. We strive to keep the spirit of mom-and-pop dining alive, ensuring each guest leaves satisfied and eager to return.